Awakening Doubt

Whether it’s the prolonged exposure to the 4 walls of my apartment, the dreary weather, the disconnection from church and work over break, or my recent studies in atheism, I’ve been experiencing a bit of doubt over the past couple weeks. Funny to think it was Christmas only two weeks ago, because I feel very far away from the joy and anticipation of that season.

My faith has experienced a bit of ebbing and flowing over the past few
years in general, as I’ve learned to think critically about what I’ve
known for years and reevaluate what I believe in light of who I am
today. Processing what I believe and how I live that out often leaves
me with nothing but shambles of ideas and insecure footing to stand on.
While I don’t try to break up my faith on purpose, this process of
honestly evaluating who Christ is and what it means to follow him has
left me with more questions than answers. I have felt that by honestly
reflecting on what I hold to be true about the gospel, about church,
about our communities, I am giving my faith an overhaul, a cleansing,
that if followed through, will help me see more clearly the important
parts of a Christ-centered life and drop a lot of the superfluous
pieces.

However, by engaging in this skepticism, I’ve become somewhat cynical
at times. Some parts of me just want to laugh at it all and throw in
the towel. Engaging doubt is a dark thing for me. It makes me question
everything about how I believe. It pulls down joy and replaces it with
sorrow.

On top of this, I’m reading The God Delusion, by renowned
atheist Richard Dawkins, right now for a book discussion group with my
former roommates. Boy, that’s just what I needed to get into right now.
My review of the book is for another post, however. Stacy and I also
just watched a similarly motivated short documentary called "The God
Who Wasn’t There." Both pieces are attacks on belief in a god and in
religion and each, in their own way, does this well. I don’t
necessarily hold either with much critical respect, being that both
fall into the same fundamentalist vein (on the opposite end of the
spectrum) as some Christian speakers who are pretty easy to write off
(i.e. Pat Robertson, Mark Driscoll). However, as I said above, the
wheels of doubt are turning and these atheistic ideas only add fuel to
the fire.

So, where does this all leave me? I feel like I’m walking this fine
line between doubt and faith, held up by hope that these honest
introspective exercises will produce a more robust faith, a humbler
faith, a faith in Christ’s love and live and God’s Word. I want to live
out my faith with authenticity and I feel like this may be a necessary
storm to walk through in order to find that. Please pray for this time
of reflection in my life.

Here’s to living up to my surname in this darkest time of the year:

Jesus and Thomas
But Thomas (who was called the Twin), one of the twelve, was not with
them when Jesus came. So the other disciples told him, “We have seen
the Lord.” But he said to them, “Unless I see the mark of the nails in
his hands, and put my finger in the mark of the nails and my hand in
his side, I will not believe."
A week later his disciples were again in the house, and Thomas was with
them. Although the doors were shut, Jesus came and stood among them and
said, “Peace be with you.” Then he said to Thomas, “Put your finger
here and see my hands. Reach out your hand and put it in my side. Do
not doubt but believe.” Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!”
Jesus said to him, “Have you believed because you have seen me? Blessed
are those who have not seen and yet have come to believe.”
John 20:24-28

** See additional comments below

This entry was written by Seth , posted on Saturday January 06 2007at 06:01 am , filed under Faith . Bookmark the permalink . Post a comment below or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

4 Responses to “Awakening Doubt”

  1. Hey Seth:

    What a fine line to walk and flirt with! What stuff do you actually just need to ignore and look past to hold on to faith? What stuff do you really need to dive into and analyze until nothing is left? I have been trudging through this for the past three years, at times I do not consider myself a believer and at others I love Jesus for what he is, nothing more, simple faith. All in all it is a stripping of my stable, black and white faith into an unknown gray void. Is that what Christ meant when he said the Right hand should not know what the Left is doing? In moments of clarity I see that God really has me in His path, but it is not as I would have thought. Keep going with it.

  2. Well dude, I don’t think you’re in the valley of the shadow of death, but Dawkins is not very nice, and doubt is kind of annoying. (I honestly just started the book today, which gives me a week with lots of alone time with Richard) I don’t know what fine line Garret was talking about specifically, but I think there is a line we don’t generally draw between cynicism and doubt. They are very different states of mind, though if we don’t draw some line around them we can cause both to consume us, or at least really piss us off. Figures like Driscoll cause me to be cynical and in some instances figures like Dawkins cause me to be doubtful, but Driscol cannot cause doubt and Dawkins has no say in the Gospel.

  3. It’s a pleasure to walk this line with you my friend…

  4. Thanks for the comments guys, I appreciate your thoughtful consideration of some of the things I’ve been working out. I thought I should clarify a bit of what I said above and address this “fine line” idea.

    As I’ve been confronted more recently with the adverse ideas and philosophy of Richard Dawkins and his blasting brand of atheism, I’ve been challenged to approach my faith more from a rationalized, scientifically spelled-out perspective. If you know me, you know that ain’t to good at that science thing, so it’s challenging when I hear well-argued, logical statements that tear down the faith I’ve known for so long and replace it with claims of delusion. So, my doubt arises as I try to piece together bits of what I believe is left in the aftermath of such an attack and move on from there.

    On the larger scale, the movement along a fine line between hope and doubt has become a very clear part of my walk with Christ. At times I feel so in touch and clear on how faith is lived out and how/why I believe. Those times are relatively easy. Other times, when I am more willing to reflect on the reasons, the actions, the attitudes of my faith, I am more open to cynicism and critique, which therefore makes belief more of a challenge. But without this challenge, without the doubt and reawakening of sores, I don’t feel like my faith would grow. I need to ask questions and maybe face the fact that there are some difficult aspects of my faith that I have to reconcile (ie: individuals who make me feel ashamed to be called a Christian, parts of the Bible which seem to contradict the love and acceptance that I know from Christ, the ability for me to so easily succumb to sin). Garrett and Jesse, these the places where I have to tear up and rebuild, destroy and deal with the shambles.

    I think in these shambles of faith I’m often left (often is the key word because I believe the process of doubt and affirmation of faith will be an ongoing, life thing) looking into the mirror with a renewed hope in catching a glimpse of Christ. It seems like something of a paradox, but when it becomes much more muddied, more dark, that’s when Christ becomes more clear. Paul was right in saying that at least right now, we do only see through the glass darkly. The smudges and shambles of faith and doubt remain, but when our faith is realized, we will see face to face.